A professional swap has a clear shape, from draining the old tank through to the inspector's sign-off. The plumber closes off and reconnects water and fuel, sets the new heater, and proves that the relief valve and flue do their jobs. Because gas, scalding water and paperwork converge in one closet, most owners hand the work over. If the trouble is broader than a replacement, the umbrella page, water heater repair and replacement, covers the rest. The sections that follow run in the order the decisions come up.
When is a water heater past saving?
Typically when the tank wall itself is wet. That means the steel has corroded through, and no part reverses it. Age plays in too: a heater well beyond ten years that keeps needing parts, or a repair estimate close to a new unit's price, tips toward replacing. A failed thermostat, element or igniter on a healthy tank is still a repair.
Other signs are rusty hot water and a rumble from sediment. A wet fitting or relief valve is a smaller problem than a split shell, and our leak repair walkthrough helps you separate them. If the only symptom is cold showers, the no hot water checklist comes first. Sometimes a fresh anode buys a sound tank extra years; the anode rod guide explains.
What will a new water heater cost?
A standard replacement runs $874 to $1,765 in Bob Vila's national figures, with $1,293 as the average. This Old House shows $800 to $2,000 for installation. No verified San Bernardino or Redlands price turned up, so treat both as a loose guide: the final number is whatever your written quote states.
What shifts the bill: tank versus tankless, gas versus electric, capacity, whether the new unit lines up with the existing connections, the venting, and anything the permit inspector requires. Tankless costs more and can demand larger gas piping or new venting. For that choice read tank vs tankless; for tankless pricing see what installation costs; for a line-by-line example visit replacement cost.
Is a permit really required to replace a water heater?
Within San Bernardino city limits, yes. The Building and Safety Division describes minor jobs like heater replacements as typically issued over the counter. Redlands includes water heaters in its over-the-counter permits, applied for through an online portal and paid in person before the permit is released. The county also asks for a plumbing permit on unincorporated land.
County Land Use Services lists water heater change-outs and tankless units as plumbing permit projects, which matters in Muscoy, Mentone, Crafton and Oak Glen. Highland and Yucaipa each have a building division, but their pages did not spell out heater rules, so phone first rather than assume. An inspector who checks the venting, gas connections and relief valve is working for your household. Under California rules, a permit job goes to a contractor who has a license from the CSLB.
Who handles the permit paperwork, and what about the gas side?
The contractor ordinarily applies and schedules the inspection, so look for that promise in the quote. Gas is where improvising is never acceptable. A gas heater has a shutoff, a flexible connector, a sediment trap and a flue, and one mistake can leak fuel or push combustion gases into the house.
Smell rotten eggs? Leave first. From a safe spot outdoors, ring SoCalGas at 1-800-427-2200, and call 911 as well if someone is in danger. SoCalGas names San Bernardino, Redlands, Highland, Yucaipa, Muscoy, Mentone and Crafton as cities it serves, but Oak Glen was not on the list, so confirm your provider. Be skeptical of any pitch that claims a ban is coming. The regional air board, meeting in June 2025, left Rules 1111 and 1121 unchanged.
Does hard water change which heater I should buy?
Not the choice so much as the lifespan. Scale builds up on elements and along the tank bottom, which costs efficiency and years. Suppliers report different hardness, and your bill shows who serves your address, so pick the matching row of the table below instead of trusting any single one.
| Supplier | Hardness reported | Year |
|---|---|---|
| San Bernardino Municipal Water | 242.67 mg/L average (range 120 to 330) | 2024 |
| East Valley Water District | 152 ppm | 2025 |
| City of Redlands, groundwater | 148 mg/L (range 100 to 200) | 2025 |
| City of Redlands, surface water | 117 mg/L (range 94 to 140) | 2025 |
| Yucaipa Valley Water District | 133.3 ppm (range 92 to 290) | 2025 |
A softener, filter or scheduled flush may suit your water. The whole-house softener guide covers the first of those.
What should the quote spell out?
It should state the heater's make, model, capacity and fuel, then itemize haul-away, connectors, valves, venting, the permit, any expansion tank and extras. Get it before work begins. A closed plumbing system frequently calls for an expansion tank; not every house has one.
Hot water will be off for hours, so wash up early and leave the heater accessible. Decide who hauls the old tank, and ask about earthquake bracing, since we have not verified each city's rule. To begin, send a request, and through us a local plumber visits and quotes. You will find our other services on the home page. If the heater is already dead, see emergency water heater repair.
Common questions
Will it take a single day?
Often yes, when a heater of the same type goes into the same spot. Moving to tankless, relocating the unit or running new venting stretches it out, and the inspector may come another day. A time estimate can go in the quote if you ask.
What do I ask before anything else?
Is the permit priced in, and tank removal too? Which valves and connectors get renewed? Who books the inspector? What is covered by the maker's warranty? Ask why this heater type fits your house, and keep the plumber's answers in writing.
Does someone have to be home?
Yes, in the sense that an adult opens up, answers questions about where the heater sits and approves any changes. Standing in the garage the whole time is unnecessary. Mention a locked gate, a loft installation or a tight closet in your request so the plumber arrives prepared.
Can I install it myself?
We advise against it. The San Bernardino, Redlands and county offices we checked require permits, a contractor license is a California requirement for permit work, and gas or venting mistakes are hazardous to everyone in the house. Your city's building division can tell you exactly what an owner is allowed to do.
Is it smarter to replace early?
When an aging heater is rusting, dripping or banging, yes: a scheduled swap beats a midnight flood and leaves time to compare quotes. A sound unit without symptoms can generally keep going with a yearly relief valve test and a check for damp.
References
- Bob Vila, water heater replacement cost, checked 2026-11-17
- This Old House, plumber cost guide (water heater installation row), checked 2026-11-17
- City of San Bernardino Building and Safety Division
- City of Redlands Building and Safety Division
- San Bernardino County Land Use Services, plumbing permits
- City of Highland, Building and Safety
- City of Yucaipa, Building and Safety
- SoCalGas, natural gas leak safety
- San Bernardino Municipal Water Department, 2024 water quality report
- East Valley Water District, 2025 water quality report
- City of Redlands, 2026 water quality report
- Yucaipa Valley Water District, 2025 water quality report
- California Contractors State License Board